(Written while reading Runes and Revenant, the latter being the last one that I’ve previously read.)
The Haruchai are a lot like Batman. I will do this perfectly or not at all.
But also, martial arts, tonal language, and collectivism? They’re Chinese Batman.
Wait, why do they have a tonal language at all? They’re natively telepathic. Why would they have developed a spoken language until they met other people? But when they meet the Vizard they speak to him just fine. Does it have more range in some circumstances? Or I guess maybe the telepathy came later.
The telepathy doesn’t really feel like a thing until the Last Chronicles. It kind of feels like it was hinted at before, and then it became just assumed knowledge, but there was no moment of revelation.
There’s a running theme of if you are good, you do not compel people to do things. Not for the greater good, not for their own good, not ever. This will only end badly for you. Which, I don’t know that in the real world it actually ends badly most of the time, but I am very much on board with the you do not compel people thing.
(One exception I can think of: Atiaran compels Foamfollower, but then he’s all, “you could have just asked”, and I guess that makes it fine. Speaking of which, she compels him using his name, and IIRC he’s reasonably clear that this sort of thing has some kind of power. This kind of power is never brought up again except for the Insequent.)
It does take this way too far, sometimes. Telling someone the consequences of their actions is not compulsion.
A related theme is how the white gold only works if it’s given willingly, but the definition of “willing” is stretched. Kasreyn’s ocular apparently counts. So does Foul’s torture of Linden to blackmail Covenant, or so he thinks.
Actually, in the first Chronicles, isn’t Foul trying to kill Covenant and take his ring? Then in the second, the ring is apparently useless unless given willingly. Is this an inconsistency, or did Foul learn better, or?
Linden, Covenant and the Haruchai all judge themselves by standards they’d never apply to anyone else. Covenant recognises it in the Haruchai; Linden recognises it in Covenant; no one recognises it in themselves.
I quite like the time travel mechanic where, as long as you don’t know what’s going to happen, you’re probably safe from introducing paradoxes. I’m not sure this mechanic would work in rationalfic, but it’s neat. It makes a certain kind of sense: everything you do is the future having a causal effect on the past, and what you do comes from what you know; the more you know about the future, the more the future is effecting the past. It’s not 100% reliable (the Theomach has to do some deliberate work), which also makes sense.
Kasreyn says that everything is flawed, so he can’t make things perfect, so he has to deliberately introduce flaws, unless he makes them with white gold which is itself flawed, in which case he can make things perfect because they were made with something flawed. This is… I can vaguely see how it might kind of make sense?
…does Mistweave ever get any direct speech? I guess he probably does, but part of me feels like he doesn’t.
There’s no writing in the Land. Fortunately, everyone seems to have a really good memory.
This time through, I developed a headcanon that the Land’s inhabitants were brown-skinned. Then partway through Runes, Liand is described as characteristically brown-skinned. Boom.
(Covenant is (headcanon) a white southern guy. The first Chronicles are about how a load of brown-skinned people need a white guy to save them, but they can’t compel him to do it, and he’s worried about the risk to himself if he tries.)
“Assuredly,” says the Mahdoubt. “Assuredly,” says the Theomach. Pretty sure I didn’t pick up on that connection first time.
Not a fan of how the Insequent are mentioned for the first time in book eight of a ten-book saga. Admittedly one of them appeared in book five, but in a way that could easily be a retcon. Linden’s not happy about it either, but the fact that she’s not happy doesn’t make me happy.
IIRC Donaldson planned the First Chronicles by themselves, and the Second and Last at the same time. But in many ways it feels like they were all planned together. Lots of elements of Covenant’s voyage (Elohim, Sandgorgons, the One Tree, ice) all get a mention in the First. The Land’s history is much richer in the First than the First and Second need it to be, e.g. with the Viles, Demondin and ur-Viles - but then it becomes integrated to the plot in the Last. Time travel is new in the Last, except that the Ranyhyn have been doing it since the First. The Insequent are just an incongruous exception to how well developed they feel.
The Worm of the World’s End is another exception, I don’t think that got mentioned in the First; it also feels kind of inconsistent with the existence of the Creator.
Linden keeps choosing to believe things because she doesn’t like the alternatives. This is terrible. Fortunately for my enjoyment, it does not protect her.